Troll cave II

Do you prefer the books or the show?

well to be fair, there are some good scenes in the show. The red wedding was definitely better in the show.

Otherwise books are better cuz you actualy know what is happening. The show is messy and you miss quite a lot of nuances which you can find in the books.

Overall till the 3rd season it was good and there were little differencies between the books and the show.
But the 4th and 5th season were kinda shit.

Wasn’t Robb stark supposed to be like 14 in the book? It would have made the red wedding a lot better in the show if he was.

yea, i am not counting that.
Everybody is younger in the books

Doesn’t make much sense for a 14 year old to lead an army and all that shit.

Well
 it is something we may or may not agree on but the fact is that its like that in the books so it has to make at least some sense.

It didnt feel wrong to me, when reading it.

I think we can both agree that the red wedding would have been much better if he was younger. :smile:

i am not really sure why would it be better if he was younger?

Because you would get to hear some kid screaming as he gets shot up with crossbow bolts, then gets his throat slit. :laughing:

seems like i have other tastes :smiley:

You’re honestly telling me you wouldn’t piss yourself at that? I thought you appreciated dark humor. I thought the red wedding was quite funny, i really had no attachment to those characters, hell i was more upset when the dire wolf died.

Robb stark was a complete dumb ass.

i dont know, the good part about that was the sneaky Lannister music and the shock when they died. I think I would be equaly horfied even if Rob would be 14yo kid.

yep, but it made more sens in the books exactly because he was just 14 yo.

i didnt like those character either, but it changed the flow of the story completely

The only part that shocked me a bit was when they stabbed his prego wife in the belly, i thought that was pretty bold of them. I’m surprised they didn’t get backlash for that.

Honestly all the starks seem kinda stupid, i liked Ned stark but he was kinda a fucking moron as well. They just blindly rush into things, and make stupid ass decisions. They all kinda went out like punks too, and hardly put up a fight.

Don’t even get me started on how retarded Sansa is.

yea, that is bit true.
But I actually understood Ned, we was just not the man of intriques.
I think that Sansa will be getting only better. but yea she is pretty dumb

Well yeah it made sense with him, because he was an “honorable” man and wanted to do the right thing. But Robb just did stupid shit like killing that one guy, and going back on the deal he had with the creepy old man who owned the bridge, then expecting him not to be pissed.

socialist prick 
didnt get my vote .

ill give him a chance . but the moment he fucks up or puts my taxes up . ill be leading the charge :smile:

What do you think about him calling moderate Muslims “Uncle toms” or the fact that he has shared a platform with ISIS members/ supporters before?

What do you mean by this? As in protest? Or are you going full sirwarriant? :smile:

this doesnt concern me . if there was any doubt , security wise regarding him , he would not be mayor . the intelligence service would likely voice such concerns at a high level and pull string to stop him running as he will now be involved in londons security to an extent

You sure? Considering the police let the rape of over 1500 children go under the radar for the sake of political correctness, would it really surprise you if they let a radical in power for the same fear of being labeled a racist?

And he did do and say those things, so it’s highly disturbing that he is now the mayor of your capitol city don’t you think? From what ive heard your Prime minister finds it disturbing as well.

thats the police 


when we are talking about an individual taking a high political role with access to files regarding the security of the capital at a time when the nation is at a state of "when not if " , we enter a some what different league .

i refuse to be drawn into "he is a terrorist , he said this , he said that " , i didnt vote for him because he doesnt support my views or the direction i want my nation/city to go in . nothing more . nothing to do with his religion , colour of skin or whatever other bollocks . if i perceive him as talking sense ill vote for him . i think he talks crap so i didnt