So when my Henry is about halfway through the rotation of the lock the “sweet spot” begins vibrating vigorously as if there is an earthquake or Henry has suddenly come down with severe late stage Parkinson’s Disease and ends up breaking the lock. Due to this I can only lockpick very easy locks. if I have about 20 lockpicks to break I can pick an easy lock. Does anyone else experience the halfway through a lock jitters?
go to controller settings in ps4 menu and turn off vibrations. Put your controller between your legs and use more fingers on the sticks. Turn the left stick to the right bottom side and start turning from there. Profit! 
So the vibration comes from my controller vibrating? I don’t even remember my controller vibrating during lockpickign but tomorrow morning I’m going to have to try that. I’ll also try starting from the bottom right.
There are two vibrations. One is done by controller itself, one is scripted in the game and it seems to depend on the distance you are from the ideal spot when you are turning. The further you are the more it vibrates. The more it vibrates the more it damages the lockpick and the bigger chance to fail. So you must try to stay at the same relative spot to the moving mechanism like in the beggining.