Fighting Ulrich: No one reacts

Fighting Ulrich the knight was a really bad experience for me:

Met Ulrich in the evening.
He says: You going to die now.
Ooook, so I fight him, and while I fight I retreat backwards towards town.

2 Guards walk past us: ZERO reaction. Civilians walk past us (they even collide with us, no flee reaction at all). And all they say: “Hu? Whats there?”

This was already a total dealbreaker for me in a game like this.

Then I fled, called my horse, and rode away. After reaching the forest, I unmounted, drank some potions and went back.
There he was, Ulrich, moving along the roadside. I approached him, and he didnt even react. So I started attacking him, and I got the game notification that told me, that people will notice if I do crimes like that. Hu?

Ulrich was already nearly dead from the first fight. But now he ran like a bunny, full speed and I had to tackle him a dozen times some kilometer long before, as after each tackle my sword arm was so slow, I often diden even hit him before he went back up and ran again. The serious inuries didnt even seem to bother him.
Finally I made it, and killed him.

Overall, so far, the worst moment for me in the game. Don’t know if any bugs where involved.

Not supposed to fight him to the death. If you talk to him i don’t think its even a speech check. Even still if you do fight him, he surrenders pretty fast if you win a little. I am sure there is a problem with how you fought him or whatever, but i don’t think you can kill him, or maybe you can. I only killed him once in 7 play throughs, but that was part of the overall story, not by the tree.

my first playthrough. he lit me up. and, i had to chain or die. and it just so happened that i chained one hit too many :frowning: he died.

if you are really strong & have a poisoned mace and combat perks you can kill him even on the horse case.
I did and rather unintentionally quick

Yeah he is a knight, pretty tough one too, even though he looks old. I think though the story parts he talks to you about really improve the game, especially if you do a little extra on the mission. He got my respect, and the first time i played, pre 1.3 atrocity, i was able to speech check through his entire mission, which was 100% the best outcome.

It is a speech check. He asks you to come to that place, then reveals he is there to kill you. Speech check failed, and he attacks.

Yeah, i guess if you aren’t good at combat that would be tough. You just have to take him to 1/2 though i think and he will surrender or talk to you. It sucks though its a speech check because after 1.5/1.6 when they nerfed the mot fk out of xp you rarely can get speech above 16 after full game play through and all the side quests. In the first game i could speech check pretty well because xp was easier to get. Donkeys that complained about you getting to good to fast ruin a huge part of the game for people.

On that side: How do you even get speech up? Through what specifially?