Is cherchez la femme timed?

I have a save right before they asked me to Kidnap Margaret if I need to go back, But anyways. I progress with bring Hare Margaret but now Nicolas will not talk to me (No option to do so) I was wondering is this quest timed? Because Im thinking of reloading and doing something else because I heard the new Ps4 patch fixes this.

Yes the part where you have to kidnap Margaret IS timed. You have to wait until you hear him blow Nicholas’s horn. If you wait too long you get the “quest failed” message at the top of your screen. However what you’re describing might be different. It COULD be that you are bringing Margaret too early. I suggest waiting until dawn (which is what he tells you to do) and wait until you hear him blow the horn before bringing Margaret. You can be on your way with Margaret over shoulder before he blows the horn, just dont get too close to where he is waiting until you hear the horn.

So when I hear the first horn, I grab her…What about Nick? Do I wait for another horn?

Well I did both and ended with the same bug (Nick will not Talk), You can actually talk to her and she will go with you.

Yes that is another way to get her to Hanekin. You can persuade her and she will go with you willingly. Now when you bring her to Hanekin, a dialogue starts where he tells you to go to Nick and get him to sign the confession. Describe what happens in your game at this point.

I find him either at his home or at the camp, THe only option i get is the pickpocket option, No talk option

I think that means you waited too long. He should be walking back to the camp by the time you bring Margaret to Hanekin.

Well when I delivered her, I went straight to Nic, He was walking from the camp to his home and there was no Talk option

Do I get anything with siding with the RObin Hood looking guys? WHat happens if I side with Nick?

Yes its a pretty nice reward for siding with hanekin hare. For siding with nick you lose access to that reward permanently.