Might interest you folks

I’ve recently started to write a novel, I’ve just posted a small segment of it onto wattpad and was hoping you guys might take a look at it considering to be on here you’re bound to a be a fan of this genre.

http://www.wattpad.com/40019903-currently-untitled

Let me know what you think guys, be honest all criticism is good criticism at the end of the day as it will make me a better writer.

This story is based around the period of 1400-1405 when I finish it but I’m literally just trying to sate my need for these type of novels because I feel like I’ve read every one out there.

I don’t know anything the historical accuracy, so I’ll just critique grammar stuff.

You connect separate sentences with commas quite frequently when it would be clearer/more accurate to separate them with periods instead. For example, the first sentence: “The robe fell heavily upon his shoulders, over the weeks he had learned to become used to the itch of the material but his sweat seemed to stem within the folds making the garment arid and cumbersome” or “Sitting at his desk he pulled out an envelope from a drawer, the seal had been broken but clearly embellished upon what was left was a mark of royalty”. In both of these examples you are putting two separate sentences into one by using commas. It reads strangely. Making sure you properly separate your sentences with periods rather than trying to force them together with commas would improve flow.

An example where you used the comma correctly is here: “His room was doused in candlelight, causing a medley of shadows to dance upon the subtle masonry”, as the post-comma part of the sentence is not a complete sentence in its own right, unlike in the previous sentences I quoted.

The orders are also written a bit awkwardly. Further punctuation should help to clarify, and separating the orders from Piers’ actions by use of paragraphs may help as well.

Back to the periods instead of commas thing, “What sordid little bastard had managed to defile his orders in such a manner, he stood up suddenly sensing a presence within the room, eyes wide with alert he began to turn when a voice pierced the darkness” was confusing for me and I wasn’t sure what was going on at first. A rough fix could be something like “What sordid little bastard had managed to defile his orders in such a manner…Suddenly, he sensed a presence within the room. He stood up, eyes wide and alert, when a voice pierced the darkness”.

The last paragraph could use a little cleaning up as well. You describe the three men independent of their names, then use their names to describe their actions. That gives me the physical appearance of three men but not what names belong to which person. Then, “The second of the larger men lifted piers to his feet and dragged him towards the window, and out over the frame. Piers glanced back into the room seeing the smaller man take one last look around before jumping out after them”. There’s a simple capitalization typo there, but more importantly the description initially doesn’t give me the impression of Piers being tossed out the window, although that’s what seems to be implied by the third man “jumping out after them”. Some clarity would help here.

Overall, not bad. I’d be interested in reading more! Hope the critique is helpful, and good luck to you.

2 Likes

@Dimetra Not reading your entire comment but I skimmed your first paragraph and I agree he does have quite a lot of comma splices. If you really wish to connect two sentences use a semicolon otherwise. Yes use a period. Comma splices are very bad grammar. (Coming from the kid that hates English and thinks that having to take at least English 30-1 is waste of time that could otherwise be spent on modeling or science)

Thank you sir I can certainly grasp what you’re saying with the periods and I will go to work fixing that asap. It’s a first draft so I am glad to have this sort of critique as like I say eventually it will make me into a better writer.

My intention was for you not to know which man was which in the house as Piers actually wouldn’t have known any of them by name. When he hears the names they’re submerged in shadow so when he actually gets too see them their stature is all he can recognize them by. The only thing I intended you to know was that the third mans name hadn’t been given up as of yet and he was clearly the one throwing out the orders. I intentionally made him reference both men whenever he gave out an order to keep their identities unlinked, but I will look back into that section tomorrow and try and make it clearer for the reader.

Thank you very much for taking the time to critique me :smiley:

So being the type of person I am I couldn’t go to bed before reading through it once more and trying to correct any grammatical errors in my fatigued state.I very much liked the honest critique you gave me and would humbly request if you could check over my quick fixes and see if they improve the writing. Like I say it’s still a work in progress, so I will be sure to look over it again many times in the future. For now though these quick fixes were needed to put the mind at rest before I sleep.

Good improvement! You said these were just quick fixes, but they certainly helped to improve clarity and overall readability. There are still a few places where there should be periods rather than commas, and there are some missing apostraphes (“king’s own request” rather than “kings own request”, that sort of thing), but it’s much better.

Feel free to keep posting updates! I’d be happy to read and critique when possible. I enjoy this sort of thing. :slight_smile: Have fun writing!

Of course I am busy over the next few days, but when I get some time to continue writing I will do so. Glad that you’ve taken an interest sir.