Don’t know what might have happened but even after starting a new game sheep became fearless - i.e. not moving at all when approached. Restarting the game doesn’t help and I wonder if there are any caches that may have become corrupted.
I’ve found a strange workaround though: When I open and close the inventory, the sheep will move right away (I was able to herd the lost sheep using this method).
Game version:
TECH_ALPHA_main_13129_114