We NEED a female warrior Protagonist!

There have been secret knight orders of only females.

Again you need to reread what i have said, not once did I say strength was the only factor.
what exactly are you basing my understanding of medieval combat on?? all I have said is that they would lose virtually all clinches, which they would. But a clinch is only one very small part of combat. Furthermore this idea that you keep spouting abouting using your opponents strength/momentum against them (which is what I think you mean when you say "Counter with weakness) isn’t some novel idea that only this woman would have. She would face opponents who are already expecting this and know how to counter it. Then what does she do? she has no advantage to use in this situation.

Having said that, why do you think in all fighting sports, women and men are kept seperate? There is a gap that can’t be bridged just by learning a few different techniques, techniques that men can learn just aswell.

Women couldn’t be Knighted, they became “Lady’s”

Source

Plenty? Maybe less than 1%. I’m pretty sure it was only one Battalion.

Poor game balancing has nothing to do with historical accuracy.

And Henry is not a peasant. You find that out later in the story.

Yeah, asking for sources on things is misogyny.

Define plenty? I think you’re not using that word correctly, would have been a very tiny amount. There are famous examples like Emma Edmonds, but she was more a spy.

Anyways, this thread is just a bunch of asshurt feminists, who throw tantrums, because i asked them for a source when they say shit like “Women being fighters could be found all over Europe”.

The fuck are you talking about you cunt? I accepted his source.

Well first thing about the viking women link you posted. You should do some more research on it aside from wiki pedia, plenty of debate surrounding it, and other “shield maiden” burials. I’ll post a link when i can.

Well, bless your heart. You really are just one big SJW, aren’t you?
Here’s a question. Is it a bad thing to just have a female protagonist in a game, like Horizon Zero Dawn? And it’s involving the matriarchy no less. You’d say no, right? So what’s wrong with having an actual historically accurate game with just a male lead where it actually makes sense?

It’s all about gender equality until it doesn’t fit your narrative.

There is no source because they were SECRET. DUH
 males


Yeah, no proof. Is it plausible, some women were able to pull off a mans disguise ? Sure. But we don’t have proof, especially for half the shit being said in this thread, like “it was very common”.

No, you said “I’ll definitely have to look more into this account”
Another insult. Befitting someone who thinks a blacksmith apprentice with little to no swordsmanship being able to infiltrate and kill a camp of battletested Cuman is historical realism

I am aware of that debate, but as far as I have seen it it boils down to: “But we have always interpreted graves like this as warroir grave.” "But they are women, so they can’t be warroirs."
The second part without any more reasoning given.

Not that it matters, just as I had to provide evidence for my claim you have to for yours.

Are you dense or just a liar? Probably both.

Insults started by you.

That’s completely fair, and i’ll post a link when i can, busy with school atm.

Suitable reply to the baseless allegation you made about what I said and in the tone you did

Where is the baseless alligation? You started insulting me calling me an “overbearing twit”, then you start complaining when insult you back a few posts later. Either you have short term memory issues, or you’re just used to being a hypocrite that you don’t even notice it anymore.

And i clearly conceded on his source, so i suggest you learn to read pal.

Read above cunt. I never made any claim about female warriors

When the fuck did i say you made a claim about female warriors you fucking lunatic.

@frelmedieval @SirWarriant
Keep it civil please
otherwise i’ll Close this


You: All i did was ask for proof of your female warrior claims,

Quote me then.

And what does that have anything to do with your post? You call me a “twit” because you’re butthurt i asked someone for a source, and even when i concede that there is an example, you start flinging your poo.

Now you’re just trying to move the goal posts because you made a complete ass of yourself.

I think you should’ve done so long time ago :joy:

Ok 10 Minutes Pause on this Topic